EU Court Adviser Backs Reviving €1.5B Google AdSense Fine

3 Min Read
https://seeklogo.com/vector-logo/339570/google-adsense

Join the Newsletter and Get 7 Days Free

Sign up

An Advocate General at the Court of Justice of the European Union has recommended overturning a lower court ruling that annulled a nearly €1.5 billion antitrust fine against Google over its AdSense for Search advertising platform.

In an Opinion delivered in Luxembourg on November 12, 2026, Advocate General Juliane Kokott stated that the General Court committed an error in law when it scrapped the European Commission’s 2019 penalty. Regulators had originally fined Google and its parent company, Alphabet, for abusing a dominant market position between 2006 and 2016 through restrictive clauses in contracts with website operators. These exclusivity, placement, and prior authorization clauses limited or prohibited websites from displaying search ads from Google’s competitors.

The General Court previously annulled the decision in September 2024, arguing that the Commission failed to adequately assess all relevant circumstances—specifically the duration of the contracts and unilateral termination rights—when proving the clauses had exclusionary effects.

Advocate General Kokott disagreed, arguing that the lower court imposed excessive legal requirements on regulators. Under established EU legal criteria, the Commission is not required to perform an exhaustive, individual analysis of every underlying contract. Instead, regulators can evaluate the cumulative impact of all significant contracts on the market and rely on overall assessments or average durations. Because the Commission met this standard for the period between March 2009 and December 2015, Kokott concluded that Google’s practices did constitute a single and continuous infringement of competition law.

Consequently, she proposed that the Court of Justice set aside the 2024 annulment and refer the case back to the General Court for a fresh judgment. Upon reconsideration, the lower court will need to rule on Google’s remaining objections regarding the size of the penalty. However, Kokott noted that the nearly €1.5 billion fine will inevitably require a reduction, as the Commission did not appeal the lower court’s earlier finding that regulators failed to prove anti-competitive effects during the year 2016.

The Advocate General’s Opinion is non-binding, and the judges of the Court of Justice will now begin their deliberations before issuing a final ruling at a later date.